Syllogistics = Monotonicity + Symmetry + Existential Import
نویسنده
چکیده
Syllogistics reduces to only two rules of inference: monotonicity and symmetry, plus a third if one wants to take existential import into account. We give an implementation that uses only the monotonicity and symmetry rules, with an addendum for the treatment of existential import. Soundness follows from the monotonicity properties and symmetry properties of the Aristotelean quantifiers, while completeness for syllogistic theory is proved by direct inspection of the valid syllogisms. Next, the valid syllogisms are decomposed in terms of the rules they involve. The implementation uses Haskell [8], and is given in ‘literate programming’ style [9].
منابع مشابه
Natural Logic for Natural Language
For a cognitive account of reasoning it is useful to factor out the syntactic aspect — the aspect that has to do with pattern matching and simple substitution — from the rest. The calculus of monotonicity, alias the calculus of natural logic, does precisely this, for it is a calculus of appropriate substitutions at marked positions in syntactic structures. We first introduce the semantic and th...
متن کاملMonotonicity and Collective Quantification
This article studies the monotonicity behavior of plural determiners that quantify over collections. Following previous work, we describe the collective interpretation of determiners such as all, some and most using generalized quantifiers of a higher type that are obtained systematically by applying a type shifting operator to the standard meanings of determiners in Generalized Quantifier Theo...
متن کاملExistential Import in Cartesian Semantics
The paper explores the existential import of universal affirmative in Descartes, Arnauld and Malebranche. Descartes holds, inconsistently, that eternal truths are true even if the subject term is empty but that a proposition with a false idea as subject is false. Malebranche extends Descartes’ truthconditions for eternal truths, which lack existential import, to all knowledge, allowing only for...
متن کاملBounds and monotonicity for the generalized Robin problem
Abstract. We consider the principal eigenvalue λ 1 (α) corresponding to ∆u = λ(α)u in Ω, ∂u ∂ν = αu on ∂Ω, with α a fixed real, and Ω ⊂ R a C bounded domain. If α > 0 and small, we derive bounds for λ 1 (α) in terms of a Stekloff-type eigenvalue; while for α > 0 large we study the behavior of its growth in terms of maximum curvature. We analyze how domain monotonicity of the principal eigenvalu...
متن کاملAn Investigation of the Composition of Iran's Import Demand: Capital, Intermediate and Consumer Goods during 1978-2004
The objective of this study has been to develop a typical specification of the Almost Ideal Demand System (AIDS) for Iranâs composition of imports including capital, intermediate and consumer goods. Accordingly, we first test the hypotheses that import demand is homothetic, homogeneous, symmetric, and depends on domestic prices. Then, we estimate the long-run elasticities of the composition o...
متن کامل